Friday, October 3, 2008

mps The... Fist Fight in Heaven

The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fist Fight in Heaven
By Sherman Alexie

This collection of short stories was has rightfully be said to startle and dazzle. It is the smartest collection of stories I’ve read to date. Using a free yet very descriptive style Alexie sets the tone for a poetic introduction to the oppressions and liberations of the Native American Culture. Alexie’s voice and word choice is dirty and honest but it is also spiritual and natural which makes it feel so pure… “Soon everybody from the party was on the lawn, dancing in the snow, fucking in the snow, fighting in the snow.” (Every Little Hurricane p.10) It’s a witty, lyrical interpretation of whom his people naturally are, laughing loving and fighting. His voice and style are also remarkably funny. It’s humor miraculously manage to dodge themes of misfortune, depression, and loss of his people. So instead of being dark or even sarcastic it is simply smart and clever. “…She named him ------- which means: He Who Crawls Silently Through the Grass with a Small Bow and One Bad Arrow Hunting for Enough Deer to Feed the Whole Tribe… We just called him James.” (Jesus Christ’s Half Brother is Alive and Well on the Spokane Indian Reservation p. 110)
It is Alexie’s voice that keeps these stories, all of which lack any sort of victory or overcoming, from being hopeless. It’s humor and honesty enveloped presence of mother earth’s character preserve us and allow us to accept that things are not good. But at least we can still laugh, we can love, and in time, yes eventually we’ll die.
I was captivated by Alexie’s story; A Train is an Order of Occurrence Designed To lead to Some Result. (P130) The story carries a theme common with most of the stories in the work. This inability the people have to fully assimilate to an American culture that is not their own. I was surprised by our main character Samuel’s optimism and than tickled by the renovations he made in his apartment (making it resembled the inside of a tipi.) eventually I was humbled as his view of the world became more familiar to the view I’ve come to know from other pieces in this work. Something like coming to terms with being at the bottom and deciding what to do about it. “Some times it’s called passing out and sometimes its called falling asleep (p138) Alexie says, after Samuel trips on the tracks of an on coming train. “ There is something about trains, drinking and being Indian with nothing to lose.” I enjoyed this intimate story of Samuel, just a fish out of water. He did his best but didn’t survive on the outside.

secretary of bestcornergroup08,

melissapierresaint





interview with sherman alexie

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZWolPAoDk3g

5 comments:

shortstories2323 said...

Hi Melissa,

I liked your comparison of Samuel as a "fish out of water." You are right on the mark. I too, liked that he renovated the inside of his apartment to look like a tipi. It reminded me of how human we all are. Even I tried to make my first apartment away from home look like home. It is such a primal instinct to make yourself comfortable in your surroundings.

Posted by: Krista Behrends

shortstories2323 said...

Thanks for the comment! Sherman Alexie is a wonderful writer and I liked your thought "about how a culture so rooted in story telling has been oppressed to a point that it hasn't been able to share one of its greatest gifts to the general culture of this nation." i agree that it is a shame that we haven't heard from more writer's like Alexie.

Posted by: Krista Behrends

Karen S said...

Hey Melissa,
That's a great interview with Alexie that you found. If we have time, I'd like to show part of it in class on the 13th.

~Karen

shortstories2323 said...

Hey Melissa I have to say I love your writing. I though that you did such a great job making these stories intertesting. Brittany

shortstories2323 said...

I also thought the part where he made his house to look like a tipi was so funny